Monday 25 February 2013

In defence of Seth MacFarlane



Seems like Seth MacFarlane is coming up tails in nearly every media outlet for being, well, racist, homophobic, and misogynistic. Key detail everyone seems to have forgotten: he does it for a living.

And a good living it is, indeed. The man is worth nine figures. His animation empire has reached a level of success rivalling Groening’s Simpsons and Parker & Stone’s South Park. At 24, he was the youngest producer/creator in network television history. I don’t care what the business; no one reaches the top of their field without being pretty damn smart.

Yesterday MacFarlane proved he was not only one of the smartest men in animation but one of the smartest on the airwaves. Throughout the entire broadcast, he was one step ahead of everyone else, and the biggest drag of the evening was that no one was even aware of it. If you ask me, his entire routine was thinly veiled criticism of Hollywood hypocrisy and folks were too drunk or sanctimonious to appreciate it.

From the onset, MacFarlane was self-deprecating and cleverly meta. Prognosticating (through Bill Shatner) the outraged headlines from tomorrow’s (today’s) Oscar coverage indicated he knew what was awaiting him and didn’t give a damn. Remember how he tried to fix it? Throwing in song and dance numbers that critics derided as superfluous. Remind you of anything? Reminds me of a bloated, ungainly, 3.5 hour presentation that the producers tried to keep afloat by inserting Chicago and Dreamgirls tributes even though neither of those films have any cultural relevance today. That’s right: MacFarlane was parodying AMPAS tactics before AMPAS even unleashed them.

(Also, in a subtle but brilliant dig, MacFarlane shoots back at criticism that he plagiarises The Simpsons by covering “Be Our Guest,” a source of inspiration for the 1995 Simpsons parody “See My Vest.”)

Everyone is making a big deal about the Chris Brown/Rihanna comment, but again I think this was smoothly calculated. Chris Brown was allowed to perform at the 2012 Grammys. Last week, at the 2013 installment, Rihanna was snuggled up to him, blissful as can be. I suppose four years is long enough to forget this happened:



Chris Brown has clearly been welcomed back by the music community AND HIS VICTIM with open arms. I saw no protest and little public outcry. This means, by default, people are okay with it. So why can’t they laugh about it? Is it perhaps because abusing women isn’t funny? Damn right it’s not, nor is it funny that today's music culture is one of aggressive anti-feminism.  Here’s my question: How is a man who did the above to Rihanna welcome to perform as if nothing had happened, but a completely separate guy with no criminal record or history of violence, simply pointing out the absurdity of their relationship not welcome? I posit because Hollywood is afraid to look itself in the mirror.

Same goes for the boob song. Everyone is up in arms, yet everyone forgets how the film industry is OBSESSED WITH BOOBS. Every time Jennifer Lopez wears a risqué, figure-hugging, or neckline-swooping dress she is put on the front cover of every magazine in town. Stylists discuss how bold or ostentatious her dress choices are. Does Nicole Kidman (who gets a mention in the infamous song) expect people to believe her breasts are real? Or her nose or face or any part of her body that makes her look like an alien? Clearly, a culture that values youthful looks to the point where women need to cut themselves is no laughing matter. Clearly, a culture where every woman on the red carpet is asked about her dress, jewelry, and makeup before her artwork is patronising and condescending to women. Score another point for Seth.

Perhaps most absurd was MacFarlane’s hiring on the heels of last year’s Ratner “scandal,” in which the producer “quit” the 84th Oscars after saying “Rehearsal is for fags” during a press conference. So what does the Academy go and do? Enlist one of the most controversial comic figures on the planet to host next year’s show. As far as I’m concerned, MacFarlane was just giving them their money’s worth. After all, he brought on a gay men’s choir and joked about the show not being able to get any gayer. Oddly, few specific mentions or direct quotations of either are to be found in reviews. Neither of these two choices has come under serious fire from critics – probably many of the same critics who were after Ratner’s blood last year.

(For the record: MacFarlane is an outspoken gay rights supporter about whom people are merely jumping to harebrained conclusions)

MacFarlane’s performance at the 85th Academy Awards was a sharp, calculated lampooning of Hollywood bombast, platitudes, and two-facedness. He was never planning on coming back. He arrived with a giant bag full of fuck yous and distributed them as he saw fit. And the audience, through its hypocritical, self-incriminating groans, played right into his hands. The joke is on you, Hollywood. So put that in your pipe and smoke it.